Homes for Sale in Wanaque, NJ
Reservoir views, classic ranches, and an outdoorsy neighborhood feel.
Homes for sale in Wanaque
Current MLS listings; updated daily. Click any property to view details, photos, and request a private tour.
Why buyers and sellers choose Wanaque.
Wanaque is a 9.6-square-mile Passaic County borough of roughly 11,800 residents; and one of the most outdoors-oriented markets in our coverage area. The borough is anchored by the massive Wanaque Reservoir (the second-largest reservoir in New Jersey, supplying drinking water to a wide swath of North Jersey) and sits at the edge of the Ramapo Mountain State Forest. The combination of substantial protected land, established residential neighborhoods, and easy I-287 access creates a borough that feels rural but isn't really; Manhattan is reachable in under 75 minutes, and the Route 23 corridor is minutes away.
Wanaque is functionally three areas in one borough: the original Wanaque section, the more developed Haskell section to the south, and the Stockholm area near Lake Stockholm to the north. Our Butler/Kinnelon office sits about 10 minutes south and works all three regularly.
Wanaque NJ homes for sale
Wanaque's housing stock breaks into three broad tiers. Entry-level Wanaque homes ($400K to $525K) are the starter ranches, capes, and smaller colonials in Haskell, plus select condos and townhomes in mixed-use developments. Mid-market Wanaque homes ($525K to $700K) are the volume anchor, with updated 3 and 4 bedroom colonials, split-levels, and expanded ranches spread across all three sections. Higher-end Wanaque homes ($700K to $1M+) include newer construction, larger lots near the reservoir, and lake-association homes on Lake Stockholm. A local Wanaque realtor who works Haskell, Wanaque, and Stockholm daily can tell you which streets trade at which prices, and which lake-association homes carry usable water access rights. With September 2026 single-family homes selling at 106.6% of list on a 2.4 month supply, buyers should come pre-approved and ready to move fast.
Wanaque NJ condos and townhomes
Wanaque has a meaningful attached-housing segment, anchored by Wanaque Reserve townhouses and similar mixed-use inventory. Per September 2026 New Jersey REALTORS data, only 2 townhouse-condo sales closed in September (a $457,000 median), a reminder of how small this segment is month to month. Year to date, 18 townhouse-condo sales closed at a $462,500 median (down 2.8%), averaging 40 days on market and 100.8% of list. Inventory sits at 6 active listings, a 2.1 month supply (up from 1.7 a year ago), so attached product is tight again and still favors sellers. Attached housing in Wanaque draws first-time buyers, downsizers, and commuters who want lower-maintenance ownership with access to Wanaque schools and Route 287.
Wanaque neighborhoods and housing stock
Wanaque's housing is largely single-family; ranches, split-levels, colonials, and a mix of older homes and post-war construction. Haskell is the more developed and densely populated section with established residential streets, the Ringwood Avenue corridor, and most of the borough's commercial activity. The Wanaque section proper sits closer to the reservoir with more wooded lots and slightly more rural character. The Lake Stockholm area at the north end offers lake-association homes with shared lake access. Pricing varies meaningfully across these three areas based on lot size, lake access, and proximity to schools.
Schools; Wanaque + Lakeland Regional High
Wanaque operates its own K-8 district with multiple elementary schools (Haskell Elementary, Wanaque Elementary) and Wanaque Middle School. For grades 9-12, Wanaque students attend Lakeland Regional High School, a regional district shared with neighboring Ringwood. Lakeland sits within Wanaque and is consistently a competitive North Jersey high school both academically and athletically. The K-8 in town, regional HS arrangement is similar to how some other surrounding towns structure their districts, and it works well for families looking for a smaller elementary experience with broader high school options.
Commute & access
Wanaque sits right along Route 287 with quick access to I-287 South into Morris County and I-287 North toward I-87 and Bergen County. Route 23 is a few minutes east via local roads, providing onward access to I-80 and points east. Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 60-80 minutes depending on traffic. The Wayne Route 23 Transit Center is roughly 15 minutes away with NJ Transit Boonton Line service to Hoboken and PATH connections.
Wanaque home prices, September 2026
Per September 2026 New Jersey REALTORS data, Wanaque single-family closings fell to 6 (vs 8 in September 2025), and the monthly median sale price came in at $555,000, down 12.6% from an unusually high September 2025. With fewer than 10 sales, one month swings on the mix of homes sold; the year-to-date median of $542,500 (down 1.4%) shows prices holding roughly steady. Homes averaged 27 days on market and sold at 106.6% of list. Active inventory is a tight 18 listings, a 2.4 month supply, up 12.5% from a year ago. That is still a strong seller's market: thin inventory and over-ask closings, even with a little more choice than last fall. Adult-community activity is steady (5 sales at a $453,000 median in September).
Seller playbook. If you own a Wanaque single-family and have thought about listing, inventory is still very thin. Correctly priced homes are drawing strong offers and closing above ask, with September homes selling in about 4 weeks, so price right from day one. Buyer playbook. Come pre-approved, be ready to see homes the day they list, and expect to compete on price and terms. Waiving minor contingencies (not inspection) can be the difference between winning and losing on the right home. For the full Morris and Passaic County breakdown, see our June 2026 Wayne/Morris market report.
Explore the rest of our market.
Questions buyers and sellers ask us.
What's the median Wanaque NJ home price?
Per September 2026 New Jersey REALTORS data, Wanaque closed only 6 single-family sales in September (vs 8 a year earlier) at a $555,000 median, down 12.6% from a strong September 2025. With so few sales, the year-to-date median of $542,500 (down 1.4%) is the better guide. Homes averaged 27 days on market and sold at 106.6% of list. Wanaque's overall home range spans entry-level $400K to $525K, mid-market $525K to $700K, and higher-end $700K to $1M+ for newer construction and Lake Stockholm inventory. Request a free home valuation for a specific home.
How fast are Wanaque homes selling in 2026?
Wanaque single-family homes still sell above asking, and the pace picked up in September. September 2026 averaged 27 days on market (down from 72 a year earlier) and closed at 106.6% of list, though only 6 homes sold, so well-priced homes still drew strong offers. Neighboring Butler (45 days, 102.9% of list) and West Milford (41 days, 100.2%) moved slower in September. With only a 2.4 month supply, Wanaque remains a strong seller's market, so buyers should be pre-approved before they tour and ready to write offers quickly.
Is now a good time to buy in Wanaque?
It's a challenging market for buyers, but a functional one with the right preparation. Wanaque's September 2026 2.4 month supply and 18 active single-family listings put it firmly in strong seller's territory (a 5 to 7 month supply is balanced, so Wanaque is running at under half of balanced). That means competing offers, over-ask closings, and speed pressure. The upside for buyers: Wanaque still offers meaningful value versus Kinnelon and coastal Bergen County towns, with real reservoir/mountain lifestyle at a $542.5K year-to-date median. Come pre-approved, be ready to move immediately, and expect to go a few percent over ask on the right home.
Do I need a Wanaque NJ realtor?
In a market with a 2.4 month supply where homes close at 106.6% of list, yes. Wanaque is functionally three separate submarkets (Haskell, Wanaque proper, Stockholm), each with different pricing, buyer profiles, and lake-association rules on Lake Stockholm. Our Butler/Kinnelon HQ office at 1481 NJ-23 S sits about 10 minutes south, and we work all three sections continuously. A local Wanaque realtor is the difference between winning your first offer and losing three in a row. Call (973) 838-3600.
What are the three sections of Wanaque?
Wanaque is functionally three areas in one borough. Haskell is the more developed and densely populated southern section with established residential streets and most of the commercial activity. The Wanaque section proper sits closer to the reservoir with more wooded lots and slightly more rural character. The Lake Stockholm area at the north end offers lake-association homes with shared lake access. Pricing varies meaningfully across all three.
What school district serves Wanaque?
Wanaque operates its own K-8 district with Haskell Elementary, Wanaque Elementary, and Wanaque Middle School. For grades 9-12, Wanaque students attend Lakeland Regional High School, a regional district shared with neighboring Ringwood. Lakeland sits within Wanaque and is consistently a competitive North Jersey high school both academically and athletically.
How's the commute from Wanaque to NYC?
Wanaque sits right along Route 287. Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 60-80 minutes via I-287 to I-80 or the Lincoln Tunnel approaches. The Wayne Route 23 Transit Center is roughly 15 minutes away with NJ Transit Boonton Line service to Hoboken and PATH connections to Manhattan.
What's the Wanaque Reservoir?
The Wanaque Reservoir is the second-largest reservoir in New Jersey, supplying drinking water to a wide swath of North Jersey. For Wanaque residents, it's a defining geographic feature; substantial protected land at the borough's center, with the Ramapo Mountain State Forest at its edge. Recreational access is limited (this is active drinking-water infrastructure), but the protected open space around it shapes the borough's character.
How does Wanaque compare to neighboring towns?
Wanaque generally offers more square footage and bigger lots per dollar than Pompton Lakes or Bloomingdale, with the trade-off of less downtown walkability. The Lakeland Regional HS is competitive with neighboring high schools. If you want more space and outdoor amenities, Wanaque often wins; if you want walkability or a Main Street downtown, neighboring towns may suit better.
Which CENTURY 21 Preferred office serves Wanaque?
Our Butler/Kinnelon (HQ) office at 1481 NJ-23 S sits about 10 minutes south of Wanaque and works all three borough sections (Wanaque, Haskell, Stockholm) regularly. Call (973) 838-3600, walk in, or request a free home valuation to start.
Buying or selling in Wanaque?
Call our Butler / Kinnelon office at (973) 838-3600 or send us a quick note. We'll set up time to walk through your goals, the market, and what comes next; no obligation.
Get My Home's Value